New technique delivers good cosmetic result without 2nd procedure
Written by Nicole Fawcett
ANN ARBOR, Mich. - The skin cancer growing on Carolyn Bohlmann's nose was not a very aggressive variety. But it was deep and located right on her nostril. The tricky part was not so much removing it MOHS surgery, the procedure Bohlmann had, is a fairly common outpatient procedure.
The tricky part would be reconstructing her nostril so that it didn't lift up or droop down. It's an important cosmetic issue, but it's also critical for breathing.
Bohlmann opted for a new reconstruction technique her surgeon, Jeffrey Moyer, M.D., was offering at the University of Michigan Comprehensive Cancer Center. Moyer removed some cartilage from behind Bohlmanns ear and skin from her shoulder and shaped it to create a new nostril in the place where the tumor had been growing.
"It healed up nicely. You can see a bit of a wrinkle, sort of a raised wrinkle. No one notices it unless I say something about having a surgery," says Bohlmann, 69.
Ten days after having the procedure done, she was back to work at the deli counter, where none of her customers said a word about her nose.
"The nose is a fairly complicated area to reconstruct," says Moyer, an associate professor of otolaryngology at the U-M Medical School and the senior author on a paper that outlines this new technique.
The most common method for nostril reconstruction requires taking cartilage from one part of the body and skin from the cheek or forehead to create a special skin flap. The skin flap stays in place for about three weeks so that the blood vessels can grow in the new spot. It looks very conspicuous during that time. Then patients come back to the operating room where surgeons finish the procedure by removing the flap. The tissue and blood vessels have grown over the cartilage, ensuring everything stays in place. Typical results look good and the nostril functions correctly.
But what about patients who can't or don't want to endure two procedures?
Moyer and his team started with one key question: Do we really need that blood supply from the skin flap? Bohlmann was one of 20 patients to take part in a clinical trial to help answer that.
The new procedure skips the skin flap and the need for a second procedure but still appears to allow for the cartilage to take hold and keep its place without the nostril either collapsing or pulling up. On a 1-5 scale (1 is best), the average cosmetic result was judged a 2.3 considered to be good to very good, with minimal scarring that was not distracting to the patients appearance. Bohlmann's result was judged as a 2.5.
"This could save people a lot of effort and time. The last thing people want to do is return to the OR," Moyer says. "It allows us to spare people multiple surgeries or a scar that dominates the cheek."
Moyer says that the cheek flap technique has a somewhat better cosmetic result than his new procedure. But since many skin cancer patients are older, they often have other medical conditions that make that second procedure unadvisable.
"The incremental benefit with a cheek flap is not worth it for some patients. The ability to do something less but still get the same quality of results is important," he says.
The results from the first 20 patients appear in JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery. Specialists at the U-M Comprehensive Cancer Center continue to offer this reconstruction technique. For information, call the Cancer AnswerLine at 800-865-1125.
Additional authors: David A. Zopf, M.D.; Wade Iams, M.D.; Jennifer C. Kim, M.D.; and Shan R. Baker, M.D.